Talk about an American classic! The sourness of this bread is quite unique, but not everyone is fond of it. For some, it’s a little excessive, but I happen to love it. In fact, I’ve considered buying a commercial SF sourdough starter to try and mimic this bread at home. However, the fact that soon that population would change by incorporating yeast and bacteria present in our own environment, made me reluctant to go for it. Sure, it would be nice to bake a few loaves with a “close to the original” taste, but then I’d be left babying three starters instead of the two I own… and I already take care of way too many strains of bacteria in the lab! 😉
Browsing through the pages of “Bread Alone,” I spotted a recipe for San Francisco Sourdough, and almost did not pay attention to it, thinking that it would involve the authentic starter. Nope. Daniel Leader developed his own recipe for it, coaching a regular starter into a slightly increased level of acidity, resulting in a bread that, according to him, would be very close to the original.
SAN FRANCISCO SOURDOUGH
(from Daniel Leader’s Bread Alone)
for the poolish
4 oz starter (mine was at 100% hydration)
4 oz bread flour
4 oz water
for the dough
8 oz water
all the poolish
13.5 to 16 oz bread flour
1/2 Tbs salt
Make the poolish the day before you want to bake the bread, by combining all the ingredients in a small bowl and leaving at room temperature for 24 hours, preferably from 74 F to 80 F, covered with plastic wrap.
Next day, pour the water at room temperature in the bowl of a KitchenAid, mixer, and add the poolish, breaking it up gently with a wooden spoon, and stirring until dissolved. Add about 1 cup (5 oz) of the total flour and the salt, and stir until combined. Place the dough hook in, keep adding the rest of the flour (you may not need all of it), and knead for about 12 minutes at the second speed of the machine.
Remove the dough to a slightly floured surface, knead it by hand a few times, place it in an oiled bowl, cover loosely with plastic wrap, and let it rise for 2.5 hours, with quick cycles of folding after 45 minutes and 1 hour and 30 minutes. After the second folding cycle, leave the dough undisturbed for the final 60 minutes of bulk fermentation.
Place the risen dough over a slightly floured surface, and without de-flating it too much, form it into a ball. Let it rise 45 minutes. Shape the dough as a boule or any other shape you prefer, place it in an appropriate container for the final rise, and leave it at room temperature for 1 hour.
Bake it in a pre-heated 450 F, with steam, for a total of 45 minutes, decreasing the temperature to 425 F after 10 minutes of baking. If using a cover to create steam, remove the cover after 30 minutes. Let it cool over a rack for a couple of hours before slicing it.
to print the recipe, click here
My main modification of the recipe was to include two folding cycles after kneading in the KitchenAid because I felt the dough lacked structure and strength. I used regular, supermarket bread flour, so it’s possible that it behaved differently from the book’s description. For the most part, I tend to bake my breads with regular bread flour, not going out of my way to find the one with “a touch of germ,”, or “harvested during Spring, under a full moon.” 😉
Did the bread deliver the promise in the taste department? YES! When I tried a piece all by itself to get the real taste of the crumb, it immediately hit me as VERY similar to a San Francisco sourdough, so if you live hundreds of miles away from the Bay Area and develop a craving for that bread, this recipe will soothe you.
A more authentic shape would be a torpedo type loaf, but I have a weakness for round bread, so that’s how I shaped mine. Round, oblong, it doesn’t really matter. It hit the spot. Awesome bread!
I am submitting this post to Yeastspotting…
ONE YEAR AGO: A Real Oscar Winner
TWO YEARS AGO: Pane Siciliano
34 thoughts on “SAN FRANCISCO SOURDOUGH”
Sally, wow! I always thought you had to live in SF to have that sort of sourdough – purists will tell you it’s in the air and the water there. I’ll have to give this a go if you think it’s that good! 🙂
Oh, I am sure it’s definitely all in the water and their own mixture of yeast/bacteria – but, this was a pretty nice approximation of it, I’ve been using this starter for quite a long time, and never had this sourness in a loaf. Worked quite well… Next time I’ll go for the traditional torpedo shape.
Pretty loaf Sally! I have no idea how sour SF sourdough is. Presumably from what you say it is down to the relatively low ratio of flour/water to mature starter in your refreshment as much as anything else. Does it sit for 24 hours before you mix it in to the dough or 12 hours, I always find ‘day’ quite a loose term, simillarly the night before, my night before can be anything up to 12 hours in real terms, but I think most people use it to mean about 7 – 8 hours. Time is the key thing here I’m guessing. What do you think?
Joanna you are absolutely right, the timing is key – I will go back and edit the post because it is 24 hours, not simply overnight (which is a very loose term).
Mine stayed at room temperature 20 hours, but I had to accommodate for my own schedule that day. Also, in his book Leader is very careful about temperatures – both for fermentation and the dough itself, carefully measuring all temperatures, air, water, flour. I didn’t do that, but for those interested, both his books “Local Breads” and “Bread Alone” use this type of approach
Wow, look at that bread. It’s literally perfect. You’re an expert Sally. Besides the caveman thing, I fear the process is too scientific for a winger like me – I’m quite certain I would not get your results 🙂 I particularly like the exterior of sourdough – a crunchy, chewy delight. (I also love San Francisco! next to Maine, it is the destination I have visited most in the US). Gorgeous loaf Sally.
far from an expert, I cringe at shaping baguettes. Must go back to it and get my lesson in humility 😉
Pingback: Further Sourdough – The Best Loaf I’ve Ever Baked « Sid's Food Fascination
I loved waking up to this recipe this morning. You know your breads are among my favorites. 🙂 I love SF sourdough. This recipe reminds me of King Arthur’s extra tangy sourdough. Yum! I’ve temporarily given up on making bread though. I’m just having a devil of a time with it. I do miss the smell of fresh bread around here though.
I was wondering if you went back to it or was still in “break mode” – take your time, maybe when Fall comes in full force you can fire your oven for a nice loaf of bread
Looks simply incredible. There’s just something about a sourdough.
Indeed, a sourdough is always special…
oooh…gorgeous loaf of bread!! I think I could smell it while reading this post!! Long ago I made a sourdough bread when I received a starter from a cooking class. I’m definitely going to try this out next time I have a day in the kitchen!
Do try it, and let me know how it goes…
será que um dia ainda farei um pão assim? o vapor me assusta, ainda não estou confortavel em assar com vapor.
imagino o sabor deste pão, show! bjs
Angela, depois que comecei a usar uma assadeira invertida sobre o pao para criar vapor, meus paes melhoraram MUITO (principalmente a crosta, nunca fica a mesma coisa sem o vapor)
estou com um metodo alternativo para tentar no futuro, se funcionar eu te mando um email, ok?
I’ve never used a special bread flour either, but now I’m curious about them! This sounds like a fabulous bread, and I like the round shape too.
I’ve bought a few bags of special flours when I was testing recipes for a bread book, and part of the deal was to stick to the flours they used. It was a big hassle, and unless the recipe is for something that requires a very high level of gluten, I now keep it simple.
Awesome sourdough loaf! Round is just fine with me.
Pingback: Musings on Sourdough « Sid's Food Fascination
Sally, I want to try this recipe. My concern, before I begin, is that in 24 hours my starter will rise, ripe, overripe and colapse. Usually, at a ratio of 1:1:1 it gets fully ripe in 4 hours at 25C.
What do you advise me to do? Go with the recipe as it is, shorten poolish time, or modify the ratio of poolish (1:5:5, for example).
Thanx a lot! this bread had hounded me from the minute you posted about it! I’ll wait your answer before I’ll begin.
Hello there! NIce to see you here…
My starter also collapsed in the 21 hours it took me to use it – I went back to my notes about it, and realized that I used it in a little less than 24 hours. I was a bit concerned about it, but decided that in this case it would probably help by increasing the level of acidity in the poolish. So, I’d say go for it as written and see what happens – maybe you could tweak the recipe a little in future bakings? I thought my crumb – well, my bread crumb 😉 – was not as open as it could have been, so perhaps there is a perfect balance to be had as far as long poolish fermentation and its bubbly character
but the taste was very very close to what I expected, so the trade off was good for me
hope to see your blog about it (by the way, your ciabatta post with the cat story was priceless, even with the horribly broken translation by google, I had a good time reading it! 😉
Pingback: San Francisco Sourdough with a twist (I) | Apa. Faina. Sare.
I started this before reading through all the comments. I allowed my starter to rise for about 26 hours (I’m awful when it comes to timing these things). It had definitely collapsed by the time I mixed it into the dough. However, though I was a little worried about what might have been sluggish rising during the fermentation, during the final proofing it rose beautifully and my crumb (see description below) was light and airy.
It’s a wet dough and I don’t have a stand mixer, so I kneaded for probably 20 minutes to build up the gluten. I’m trying to work on my kneading and my feel for the dough, so it was a pleasure.
Now, the loaf is ugly mostly because the crust is disappointingly soft (this is my first soft loaf – per your comments on my last comment, I really need to work on the steam), but the crumb is my best yet! There are tons of beautiful, uneven air pockets. And the flavor is really nice.
Question: I think maybe I need to buy a lame because I’m not getting the bursting at the sites of the scoring that I see you (and others) do. I see some extrusion near the base of my loaves, so the dough is looking for someplace to expand. Off the top of your head, are there other reasons why I might be having problems with this lack of bursting? (and is there a technical term for bursting/eruption?)
Thanks again for a lovely recipe!
Great that you got a nice crumb, uneven holes is what everybody loves!
The “technical term” I guess would be “oven spring” – and probably the most important part of getting a great oven spring is creating structure in the dough by proper folding and creating “surface tension” when you do the final shaping. The surface tension comes from sort of “stretching” the surface of the dough as you shape, and the only way to get there is watching the many youtubes around showing real pros doing it, and then: practice, practice, practice.
I now think I can do it reasonably well with a round shape bread, but my technique is lousy with batards and despicable with baguettes – you may be interested to know that 2012 will be the year I’ll conquer the baguette shaping! (says Sally, with all fingers crossed, and a ton of self doubts in her mind)…
anyway, deciding to do it is the first step, and I really want to get there, my baguette shaping is pathetic.
anyway, if you have a very active starter, then you master the folding to the point that you “feel” when the dough is strong, you are 80% there. All you need is the surface tension and the slashing… and yes, definitely a blade makes it better. When you do the slashing, be firm and decisive. Show the bread who is the boss, but don’t butcher it 😉
glad to know you are having so much fun, I must bake a bread next weekend, once I’m done traveling
I’ve continued using this recipe as my go-to practice recipe. My kneading technique is more efficient (particularly after I realized I was breaking the gluten strands I was trying to develop), I have a much better “feel” for the dough, the flavor of my breads better developed (after I switched to daily starter feedings), my shaping…improving, but still no/little oven spring.
I think my poor shaping technique definitely has something to do with it (thanks so much for explaining that to me!), however I chanced upon a wonderful old cast iron dutch oven in an army surplus store on a recent New Mexico camping trip and used it to bake up a loaf immediately after returning home. I cannot express my glee upon removing the lid after 15 minutes. Beautiful, buttery crust and amazing uplift. I’m really surprised it would make such a difference. This doesn’t excuse me from continuing to improve my shaping technique, but at least I can enjoy better bread in the meantime.
Thanks again for your lovely recipes, thorough commentary, and very thoughtful comments/responses!
Your comment gave me a huge smile, of course… I remember too well the first time I had a nice bread, and like you, I could not believe when I opened the oven and uncovered the bread… that amazing beauty finally there!
I am glad you found this cast iron dutch oven, because it can make all the difference in the world! I struggle with generating steam, but no matter what many people tell me, nothing beats the covered environment for the type of crust I like – and I guess you do too…
Enjoy your adventures! 🙂
Thank you for sharing this recipe. I made it yesterday and it was fantastic. My most successful sourdough to date. I will be making this again and again.
Awesome, Amy! Nothing like a bread recipe that “works”! 🙂
Thanks for the feedback, I appreciate it!
I just found your blog and I love it!! I’m going to try this recipe right now. I recently had surgery on my shoulder and decided since I was going to have a lot of down time I would try my hand at a wild yeast starter. I got directions from Peter Reinhart on making a whole wheat wild starter and it worked wonderfully. My only problem is I travel for a living so I can’t feed my starter twice a day like you. Do you have any recommendations on what I can do to keep my starter going? Also you mentioned that you have two starters. What two do you have?
Welcome to the Bewitching Kitchen! I don’t feed my starter twice each day, I might do that ONLY on the day before baking, because even though I don’t travel for a living, my life is plenty busy and if I had to feed a starter twice a day I might just give up baking bread! 😉 I actually now refresh my starter from frozen, I make a firm starter, maybe 75% hydration, and once it’s done bubbling I form into small balls and freeze them individually on a tray. Four days before baking I remove one ball from the freezer, dissolve in water and refresh it with flour at the desired hydration level. I refresh once a day, maybe the day before baking I do it twice. It’s been working, before doing that I kept the starter in the fridge, but I had problems, the poor thing was in horrible shape, could not leaven bread to save its own life… 🙂 Don’t tell anyone, but now I have only one starter, my own. I allowed the commercial one to die a peaceful death. I could not justify the trouble of keeping two going… It was from King Arthur, by the way.
THanks for your comment!
Can you use a Dutch oven to get the crusty outside?
I think it could eork quite well! Let me know if you try it, ok?
Have you ever baked this recipe in a dutch oven?
YES! works perfectly too….